The Critic in Me

I have been talking to myself since I could, talk to myself… The secrets my mirror could tell. Gee whizz! Standing there, rehearsing, and scripting what to say, sometimes giving myself a little edit. Actually, I always give myself a little edit. 

Now, it is true that my career background is varied and colourful. I trained many moons ago in drama and scriptwriting, and worked in TV production for a long time. So am I a drama queen? Yes. But this boils down to far more than my age-old aspirations to be the next Blue Peter presenter as I’m still self-scripting now! 

This has ‘anxiety’ written all over it. So I put it to you, dear GAWD readers, am I the only one that has a little rehearsal before speaking out loud? Also, is this a helpful trait? 

Say What?!

So basically, I’m a fraud then! It is official. For those that know me, you might be a little surprised to read this claptrap. I probably always manage to come across as self-assured, confident, knowledgeable even.

You thought I was good at the art of the chat. Rolls off the tongue, and a one-take wonder. But little did you know, those words of wisdom had been practised. There had been a raft of edits and reruns long before I put brain to voice box.

I am hamming it up slightly. I don’t rehearse every little thing that comes out of my Brummie gob. (More’s the pity some might say.) It’s when I’m anxious that I start to script myself, in order to prepare what I’m going to blurt out. Particularly when I’m with strangers or challenging situations.

Bad Rep

Self-scripting is not all bad, sometimes this method can be helpful. There are times when conversations require sensitivity and careful planning, and quite frankly, we should pause for a moment’s thought, before open the mouth box.

I find it is also helpful to have a little script when I have to deliver unfavourable news, usually to my kids. “I’m sorry, but I won’t buy you the ride-on Lamborghini car toy that costs more than my actual Kia Sportage did. But I will buy you a poster of the car. That OK?” If I’m nervous about how the news will land, preparing myself seems like a good idea.

But this often backfires, as anxiety takes over and pulls me away from really listening in the moment. I’m just stuck in my own head. This can also make it harder for ideas to come up naturally based on what the other person is saying. Swotting up too much feels like hard work, and feeds the idea that I need to say things perfectly to be accepted. That just adds pressure, keeps anxiety spiralling, conversations feel a bit unnatural and robotic. 

Speak Up!

I’ve been known to rehearse speech chat and when I go to utter the words I bumble. It’s such a deflating experience. I’m so consumed by anxiety and no matter how hard I rehearse, the words won’t form. A growl or a squeak makes its way out. Like anxiety has my voice and brain box, strangling it. Or I babble and spit and dribble. I think you get the picture, and what an image that must be. 

I do, I talk to myself, in my head, but sometimes out loud. “What? I know. What she said…”

I believe it is a coping mechanism. A tool I’ve used to make myself feel better or entertain myself. It’s not all anxiety driven and bad. At times, it can be a helpful affirmation or two. “You’ve got this.” “Get off your lazy b*** and get on with it.” You know those kinds of helpful nuggets. But then the sneaky little negative scampers creep in,  “Got what? What you got? You’ve got nothing. You’re no one. Nothing. Nobody.” (My words, to me.)

Have a Word

You’re about to talk to someone, maybe a colleague, a friend, or a bloke down Saino’s, and suddenly your brain decides it’s time to host your own chat show, complete with an inner autocue of intrusive thoughts, and a mental script that could rival a Shakespearean monologue.

Unpicking this a bit and after many therapy sessions, I realised my conversational anxiety had two main bad guys of blather:

1. The Running Commentary Gremlin

This one’s a right pain in the backside. Picture an overly opinionated sports commentator on race day, giving live updates on your every move – 

“Oh no, she’s stumbled over that sentence… awkward, wasn’t it? Ooof, risky subject there, love, not your best work.”

This demon thrives on intrusive thoughts, the “what if I sound silly?” and “they must think I’m stupid” variety. Psychologically speaking, we’re talking classic negative self-talk, the sort CBT therapists love to unpack.

The thing is, my brain thinks it’s being helpful. It’s trying to prepare me, keep me safe from social embarrassment. But it’s like having an oversensitive alarm that goes off every time you inhale to utter a word. 

Trick the Thoughts

One thing I have found that works is that I try not to wrestle with my negative thoughts,  just I acknowledge them. Then I pop a mental post-it note on them. Like “Anxious Brain.” Naming and shaming these thoughts allows you the distance to be able to stand away from it.

2. The Over-Scripting Demon

Then there’s this little tyke. The planner. The overthinker. The perfectionist playwright in my head who insists on rehearsing every possible conversation like it’s opening night.

With my psychology hat on I can call this a safety behaviour,  my brain’s attempt to control an uncertain situation. “If I can prepare exactly what to say, I won’t look like a fool.” Trouble is, that just fuels more anxiety. I end up performing, not connecting.

Time for a bit of Improv.

Try dropping the script. Go in with curiosity rather than choreographed moves. Focus on listening rather than delivering. When your brain starts drafting lines again, gently remind yourself, we are not giving evidence in court; it’s just small talk about the weather with a colleague.

If a warm-up is needed, grounding techniques can be useful, take a few slow breaths, feel your feet on the floor, or sip your tea like a mindfulness master. Sometimes, we just need that little reminder that we’re safe and not on stage.

Chat Back

Both of these mental mischief-makers, the Running Commentary Gremlin and the Over-Scripting Demon, have been stealing the fun from my conversations for far too long. So I’ve decided to have a strong word with them. It’s not about silencing the inner voice entirely, that’s impossible and, honestly, not necessary. It’s about learning to spot it, laugh at it, and carry on living anyway.

Because I’ve realised that life’s too short to let imaginary critics run the show. Sometimes, the best conversations happen when I stop trying so hard and just let myself be gloriously, imperfectly me.

Now Listen Here 

That inner commentator and scriptwriter? They’re not the baddies, really. Just overworked actors who’ve missed the final curtain call.

So next time your mind starts rehearsing a conversation like it’s an episode of Brookside, pause. Take a breath. Remember that most people aren’t analysing your chat, they’re too busy worrying about their own.

Try swapping perfection for presence. Chatting is messy, human, unpredictable, and that’s exactly what makes it brilliant.

TTFN.

Comments

2 responses to “The Critic in Me”

  1. Carol Cox Avatar
    Carol Cox

    Well written Kelly. I do lots of ‘rehearsing‘ at times. As I have found out in the past, speaking out straight away has got me into trouble on more than one occasion! Giving yourself time to breathe and think about the situation is so much better.

    Always thought of you as my confident, independent, intelligent daughter. You are all of these but the difficulties you have encountered over the last year are bound to ‘try’ anyone.

    You are doing amazing. Keep doing what you are doing. Always here if you need me.

    Love you x

    1. Kelly Avatar
      Kelly

      Thanks ma, lots of love back x

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *