Over the years I have noted that my go-to behavioural response to intrusive thoughts is proof-seeking. I go on a one-woman-mission to prove that the heightened, often delusional thoughts I am having, are actually true. It’s not pretty, it’s not clever, and it can make life pretty tough at times
Come to think of it, does anyone else have a troubling voice, forever doubting you, making you feel worthless and useless? I feel I must point out immediately, when I say “voice” I mean, my thoughts, my internal voice. Not auditory hallucinations. Those are perceptions of sounds, including voices, music, or other noises, that occur without any external source. Read more on that from the National Library of Medicine.
The voices I am talking about in this post, are more like an internal echo talking back to me. Anxiety-driven rumination over past, present, and future decisions. They often pop-up without any warning.
The Science Behind the Thoughts of Doom
Intrusive thoughts are anxiety’s bread and butter. They usually involve worries that trigger feelings of fear, guilt and uncertainty. These thoughts rarely reflect reality for me, but when you’re heightened and in the throes of an anxiety spiral they seem so real, and they can trigger an intense emotional response. This is where the brain’s fight-or-flight system gets turned on. It might well have been handy back at the dawn of time, for survival. However, the modern world does not warrant the need to be in a constant state of fight-or-flight mode .
Proof-seeking? Go Figure!
The brain’s prefrontal cortex is responsible for functions like decision-making and problem-solving, while the amygdala plays a key role in processing emotions like fear. When we experience an intrusive thought, our amygdala may trigger a stress response, sending us into a state of heightened anxiety. The brain then tries to make sense of the anxiety by seeking proof, whether through rational analysis or checking behaviors, that either confirms or disproves the negative thought.
Proof-Seeking Sucks!
Proof-seeking can take many forms: asking others for reassurance, Googling to verify fears, or mentally replaying situations to search for signs that the thought is true. As I alluded to earlier, at my worst, I have been known to go and make my intrusive thoughts become a reality.
Supermarket Blowout
I was in a huge superstore with my mum, anxiety levels were high, I was grinding my teeth, I felt like I was walking around in a dream, sweating and shaking. A real picture. I was convinced that some people in the store were looking at me and talking about me. What proceeded to unfold was an extreme case of proof-seeking.
I needed my mum to believe that people were talking about me. So I proceeded to march her from the aisle where she was, point out these poor people choosing some eggs, and flap about in a heightened manner; which quite frankly did cause the people to look at me, and also probably comment about me. To be honest, they might have been worried for their safety… But in that moment, I felt vindicated, I had proved that those people were talking about me. Then I crumbled in a heap and sobbed.
Game Changer
It might not surprise you to hear that type of behaviour mentioned above, often backfires. It may provide temporary relief, but it reinforces the cycle of anxiety. The more we search for proof, the more we reinforce the idea that our negative thoughts might be true, even if they aren’t.
Plus it becomes like a vicious cycle. The brain becomes addicted to the relief that comes from seeking the proof, but that relief is short-lived. The anxiety inevitably returns, and the need for more proof grows, keeping us stuck in the cycle of worry and rumination.
Read more on that here.
Termination of Rumination
The good news is that there are effective strategies to disrupt this cycle and reduce anxiety caused by proof-seeking behaviours.
Serious Note:
If your thoughts and proof-seeking are accompanied by persistent low mood, and you have been struggling. It could be the time to reach out to a GP, or get mental health support. I’ll add some resources at the end.
For now here are some suggestions of how to halt the proof-seeking.
1. Understand Your Triggers
Identify Specific Situations. Jot down when you feel the urge to seek proof.
Look for common themes and see if you can notice patterns, you’ll be armed and ready to process them.
2. Set Boundaries for Seeking Reassurance
Limit proof-seeking. Resist the urge. Or set time restrictions on when you’ll engage in proof-seeking behviours like; checking emails or text messages.
3. Develop Self-Soothing Techniques
Breathing Exercises. Practice deep breathing techniques. Inhale for a count of four, hold for four, and exhale for a count of four. These mindful techniques help you curb the urgency to seek proof.
4. Challenge Negative Thoughts
Cognitive Restructuring. Identify negative thoughts associated with proof-seeking and challenge them. For example, try saying out loud. “I can trust my own judgment. I did not say anything to upset anyone.” Gather evidence that supports your self-worth or decisions.
5. Practice Self-Compassion
Cut yourself some slack! Acknowledge that everyone experiences doubt and uncertainty. Treat yourself with the same kindness you would offer a friend.
6. Challenge the Need for Certainty
Proof-seeking is largely driven by the need for certainty, as anxiety thrives on doubt. Yet, certainty is often unattainable, and pursuing it can heighten anxiety. Embracing uncertainty instead of demanding proof can be liberating.
Proof Enough
Anxiety and proof-seeking are bed fellows, with the brain attempting to find comfort and certainty in an uncertain world. Understanding the science behind these behaviours can help us turf proof seeking out, get control over our thoughts and hopefully reduce levels of anxiety.
Find a strategy that works for you. It does take practice, and there will be days that you will still be tempted to proof-seek, we all do it. I’m working hard to trust my judgement and trust that I did my best in that moment. We can’t please everyone, but we can please ourselves.
TTFN.
Leave a Reply